Fillychan

>>508
I like this stuff until remain a parody or a joke: their stupidity pluck ever some smile from me. :D
Pinkamena of Cupcakes is one of the most stupid thing of the fandom, but the jokes about the darker double personality of Pinkie Pie are some I find most funny. :p

There a couple of thing of fan stuff that I find good as concept, but the fandom in general haven't the skill to develop then in a interesting manner.

And you forgot Celestia and Bananas. That is the most randomic think ever did to a character from the fandom. ;)

>Twilight Sparkle: Not only did they turn "adorkable" into a word, they turned "OCD" into a compliment. Okay, I admit it, that's two traits given to her.

I would blame the writer staff for that. :D

>Muffins: The portrayal of "I just don't know what went wrong" was a thing for a while, but now the absolute entirety of her character can be summarised as "muffinsmuffinsmuffinsmuffins".

I find that the actual portrait in the fandom is more mild than in the first time, where she sometime was a complete idiot.
But I like see her like an absent-minded and kind mare, her clumsiness given becouse she has her head in the clouds.
Time ago was more frequent than today, but I also like see Dinky as her daughter, becouse that make Derpy the only "revelant" character that is a parent (yes, there are the Cakes in the canon, but the general interest for them is so rare that is like they are no-existant in the fandom).

>Lyra: Based on sitting on a few benches, and a two-second scene with a foamhand in Sonic Rainboom, you've made her into "handshandshandshands".

I find funny her weird behaviour, even if the jokes around her are raw. I find amusing thinking her a parody of the fans or fandom of something in general: if we likes little coloured horses (or anything else you want), then a horse could likes little silly humans. ;)

>Luna: As I don't want to spend three paragraphs on listing all the errors with her, I'll try to summarise a bit.

I think the most bigger misconception is that she was banished ON the moon, even the IDW comics make this silly error. The canon says that she was banished IN the moon. Is like say that her body fused with the aster, and her spirit caged there.
I guess that her metaphysical situation is hard to grasp...

Luna ON the moon gives some funny jokes, but I guess that very few people has enough imagination to think what mean being disembodied and imprisoned into a celestial body. :p

But I quite agree on the fact she could be at least nostalgic or sad for the lost time: things change very much in centuries, and adapting to the moder time is an hard thing.

>>514
There's a lot of characterism details in your post that I had completely forgot about, but that I now remember as clear as daylight again. Like if the characters in Kingdom Hearts on a random rainy day suddenly began to feel again.

>And you forgot Celestia and Bananas. That is the most randomic think ever did to a character from the fandom. ;)
That was in perhaps January 2011 or so. Now everyone (except the nostalgics, of which I may or may not be one) hope to one day forget about it in the same way they've tried to forget John Madden and Dover Boys.

>Pinkamena of Cupcakes is one of the most stupid thing of the fandom, but the jokes about the darker double personality of Pinkie Pie are some I find most funny. :p
There were some good Ask Tumblrs back in the days involving Pinkamena, and I saw several happy-pony-era Ponychanners use them as avatars to their posts.

>I find that the actual portrait in the fandom is more mild than in the first time, where she sometime was a complete idiot.
But I like see her like an absent-minded and kind mare, her clumsiness given becouse she has her head in the clouds.
Hmm... that's right. Since episode 100 was about fan-portrayals, and Muffins didn't seem completely incompetent in the 10 or so seconds I've seen of it, she must have become less dumb in the fans' eyes. "Absent-minded and kind" is how most people perceived her back when she "was" a mailmare, though I must admit I grew tired of the fanworks where she was a mailmare sometime in early 2013.

>if we likes little coloured horses (or anything else you want), then a horse could likes little silly humans. ;)
I think that was how a lot of the early Lyra human jokes were in fact shaped as. Humanchan, Earth Daily, such jokes involving Lyra were commonplace once upon a time, and they were likeable. I can't remember when those good times ended, because I now can't see any other jokes being done nowadays than "handshandshandshands"...

>I think the most bigger misconception is that she was banished ON the moon, even the IDW comics make this silly error. The canon says that she was banished IN the moon. Is like say that her body fused with the aster, and her spirit caged there.
I guess that her metaphysical situation is hard to grasp...
I know that Zejgar has walked over dead bodies to point out that Luna in fact was in the moon, but I was unsure about how strict the canon was on that, so I couldn't rule out the last 1/20th of her being on the moon. Now I remember that it was pretty strict on that, in fact (PTS should have been enough proof).

>>514
>Pinkamena of Cupcakes is one of the most stupid thing of the fandom
This statement is true for all the wrong reasons: Cupcakes didn't have Pinkamena in it, it had the ordinary Pinkie Pie, hair style and all that. Speaking as a guy who adores the fanfic.

>>516
>I guess that her metaphysical situation is hard to grasp...
>I know that Zejgar has walked over dead bodies to point out that Luna in fact was in the moon, but I was unsure about how strict the canon was on that, so I couldn't rule out the last 1/20th of her being on the moon. Now I remember that it was pretty strict on that, in fact (PTS should have been enough proof).
Once upon a time there was a Q&A session with Lauren, which had the following Q/A:
>Q: Where was Celestia when NMM appeared? Don't answer if you never thought of it beforehand. Don't wanna destroy anybody's theories.
>A: In my mind, they were still young and still lived in the same castle together--- perhaps with their parents. It was the ruined castle in the Everfree Forest that was featured in the premiere episode. Before she appeared in Ponyvile, NMM went to Canterlot to find Celestia and use magic to banish Celestia in the Sun. REVENGE!

If after that somebody still would say that Luna was ON the moon, then I don't know what to say. Unless you dismiss Faust's words as kidding around or talking basolute gibberish, this is quite a solid argument for "she was not on the bloody surface".

S1E01's book said "banished her permanently in the moon".

>>514
>There a couple of thing of fan stuff that I find good as concept, but the fandom in general haven't the skill to develop then in a interesting manner.
There are some serious fan fiction stories that seem to describe individual main and background ponies so well that they can be considered better definition of them than the series. but all of them are alternate settings and won't be discussed much in the open anyway. Like planets orbiting the canon that incoming spaceships won't always see because they don't shine on tv.

>Pinkamena of Cupcakes is one of the most stupid thing of the fandom, but the jokes about the darker double personality of Pinkie Pie are some I find most funny. :p
Just as much as out of control versions of Twilight, Trixie and others, which are not even OOC because they do go out of control in the series. Sort of exaggeration of exaggeration, which wouldn't have happened if canon situations weren't intentionally made confusing (S2E3, S3E5).
One episode is enough to make any pony a monster...